In This Article 3
Oleg Shibanov
What does this crisis look like
How much will the crisis in Russia in 2020 differ from the crisis of the early 1990s? A blow to small and medium-sized businesses can lead to a fall in all components of disposable income, except for social benefits. This is a serious problem. But for most macro indicators, we are in a completely different position, so we should not expect problems in the banking sector or with the public debt. The external environment is also different – stable inflation, the willingness of other countries to help their economies and low interest rates.
Here the dynamics of many indicators of the US economy allows us to think about comparisons. Only not with the crisis of 2008-2009, but rather with the Great Depression of the 1930s. Probably the main thing is the number of “new unemployed”: in the past four weeks, for the first time, a total of 22 million Americans have applied for benefits . Against the background of the workforce aged 15 to 64, at 154 million people, this looks like substantial growth. Of course, some of the applications are related to an additional unemployment benefit ( $ 600 per week for six months). And still the signal looks unpleasant.
Russia so far looks different – and short-term unemployment is likely to remain relatively low. It was at 4.5% in February and is unlikely to be above 5% in March. Measures to support the salaries of company employees, which are proposed by the state, are not so attractive for business, since they compensate for only one minimum wage. Unemployment benefits – the same. It turns out that Russians, unlike the Americans, have no compelling reasons to quit. Small and medium business in Russia in employment is about 18 million people – out of 75 million able-bodied people. If at least half is affected by the drop in demand, unemployment within the year may turn out to be double-digit. But still, the difference from the 1990s is radical.
What is the difference from the 1990s
As we recall, since 1990, unemployment has gradually grown and reached a maximum of 13.8% in 1998. The decline in GDP, which was then observed almost every year and in the end exceeded 40%, led to a drop in real wages by almost 60%. And since salaries make up the bulk of income (more than 50%, another about 19% are social payments), this decrease killed the purchasing power of the majority. But this is not at all like the current crisis.
The state of the Russian economy is now completely different: low public debt (about 15% of GDP); inflation near the goals of the Central Bank in 4% and even lower; international reserves are greater than the total external debt of companies and the state. Central banks and governments, especially developed countries, are going to actively work to support demand through lower rates, fiscal measures and medical actions.
Yes, the trigger for Russia is the fall in oil prices, which is already very reminiscent of the beginning of the 1990s, but the economy has not yet fully felt it, and the new OPEC + agreement should stabilize quotes by the end of the year. Due to the budget rule, the foreign exchange market lives at a fairly stable ruble – do not expect a sharp depreciation.
Measures by the Central Bank and the government so far seem limited in scope, but at the same time, the recent statement by Minister of Economic Development Maxim Reshetnikov to Vladimir Pozner last week once again marked an important point: the government understands that the measures will have to be expanded, and it is working on it, and the speed of decision-making to support the affected industries, apparently increased.
What’s next
The fall in real wages by 60%, or even by an average annual 8%, as was the case in 1990-1998, can be expected only with a slow reaction of the government to the May wave of the crisis.
Analysts have very different estimates of the change in Russia’s GDP in 2020. Someone predicts up to -10%, while someone else receives -2-3%. At the same time, this change will especially affect business (the share of 6.1% in income due to lower demand in the economy) and other cash receipts (12.4% in income due to lower interest rates), although salaries will be affected. Therefore, the expected drop in real disposable income can range from 3% to 5%, and only in the unlikely situation of strict quarantine could we see a 10�crease until November. It should be borne in mind that this will soon be a temporary phenomenon, and in 2021 the economy should recover.
In addition, the Russian labor market is very specific. It was characterized by a gradual transition of workers from the formal corporate sector to the informal, which at the same time greatly inhibits the growth of labor productivity. But at the same time, unemployment in the economy did not grow, and even decreased over the past few years. The level of 4.5% in February 2020 is a historic low. Therefore, after the recovery of demand in the second half of the year, it is likely that it will gradually decrease from double-digit numbers.
To summarize: I do not see any serious similarities between this crisis and the beginning or even the end of the 1990s. At the same time, of course, support measures should be implemented quickly to enable businesses to return to work as soon as the authorities remove medical restrictions.
Oleg Shibanov, director of the Skolkovo Center for Research in Financial Technologies and Digital Economics, to evaluate NES.
This article was originally published on The Bell.
Views in this article are author’s own and do not necessarily reflect CGS policy.



