Centre for Governance Studies, Dhaka

Human Rights

As part of a series of dialogues organized by the Centre for Governance Studies (CGS) on the priority areas of reform for the interim government, a discussion on human rights was held on September 28, 2024 (Saturday), at the Bangladesh Institute of International and Strategic Studies (BIISS) auditorium, Dhaka. This dialogue examined the state of the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC), its limitations, necessary reforms, and broader human rights protections in Bangladesh. A summary of the key discussions is presented below.

Ensuring an Independent Law Enforcement and Judiciary

Participants in the dialogue emphasized that while human rights violations occur in every country, what sets Bangladesh apart is the absence of accountability and the inability to seek justice for such violations. They pointed out that victims rarely get a chance to voice their grievances, and even when they do, their cases often remain unresolved due to systemic flaws.

A key issue raised by participants was the lack of independence within the judiciary and law enforcement agencies. Many discussants argued that without substantial judicial reforms, addressing human rights violations would be nearly impossible. They stressed the importance of ensuring that institutions serving the public remain free from political influence so that they do not become tools of repression under any future government.

Participants particularly criticized the role of the police force in human rights violations, raising concerns about how law enforcement officers were authorized to use weapons and how those weapons ended up in the hands of plainclothes officers, leading to extrajudicial killings and enforced disappearances. Several participants called for a thorough investigation into police operations to address these concerns.

Another major obstacle to human rights protection, according to the discussants, is law enforcement’s history of repression. To prevent future abuses, participants argued that accountability must be enforced through exemplary punishments. They warned that if impunity persists, human rights violations will continue.

Additionally, participants highlighted the controversial role of the Rapid Action Battalion (RAB), which has been portrayed as an elite force by the state and the media. However, they noted that international sanctions have been imposed on RAB due to human rights violations, raising serious concerns about its operations. Given this situation, many participants strongly recommended completely disbanding RAB to prevent further human rights abuses.

Enhancing the Independence and Effectiveness of the NHRC

Participants emphasized that human rights awareness should be promoted at all levels, including schools, colleges, and universities. However, they pointed out that the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC), which should be at the forefront of these efforts, lacks independence and effectiveness. Several discussants argued that structural reforms are necessary to empower the NHRC so that it can operate as a genuine rights-protecting body.

Currently, participants identified several major limitations of the NHRC:

Lack of independence – The NHRC cannot function freely without government influence.

Restricted investigative powers – Although it can conduct investigations, the NHRC is not permitted to publish reports publicly. Instead, findings are submitted only to the government.

Inability to file lawsuits – The NHRC does not have the legal authority to initiate cases related to human rights violations.

Additionally, discussants noted

that while the NHRC has regional offices outside Dhaka, public awareness of these offices is extremely low. These offices, they argued, exist primarily for bureaucratic purposes and do not actively contribute to protecting human rights.

Participants also pointed to reports highlighting systemic discrimination against indigenous communities. Some discussants mentioned cases in which Santal and other indigenous groups face segregation in hotels and public spaces, where they are forced to use separate utensils or are denied entry altogether. These examples, they argued, underscore the failure of institutions like the NHRC in tackling deep-rooted discrimination.

To improve credibility, participants strongly recommended legislative reforms to ensure NHRC’s independence and transparency. They warned that public confidence in the commission has declined significantly, with some participants comparing it to state-run media like BTV, which many people no longer trust.

State-Sanctioned Human Rights Violations and Ways to Prevent Them

Discussants categorized state-sponsored human rights violations in Bangladesh into two main forms:

Killing before arrest – Extrajudicial executions carried out without due process.

Killing after arrest – The execution of detainees while they are in state custody.

Participants found the latter particularly alarming, as detainees should be under full state protection once arrested. They cited reports showing that over the past 16 years, more than 200 individuals have been killed while in custody.

To document these violations, several participants proposed establishing a Truth and Reconciliation Commission or a similar body. They suggested drawing lessons from South Africa’s Truth and Reconciliation Commission, which documented victim testimonies and preserved records to prevent the erasure of past atrocities. Participants warned that if Bangladesh does not properly document these injustices, future generations will not remember them, allowing history to repeat itself.

Some discussants noted that an independent group of students has already created a website to track human rights violations during the July movement. However, they argued that the government and NHRC should have taken the initiative to create such a platform. Additionally, participants pointed out that international best practices suggest establishing psychological rehabilitation programs for victims and creating platforms for public apologies from perpetrators as essential steps for acknowledgment and healing.

To enhance accountability, some participants proposed holding public hearings, similar to U.S. Congressional Senate hearings, where state institutions and law enforcement agencies can be questioned about human rights violations.

Empowering Civil Society and Human Rights Organizations

Participants strongly criticized the Prime Minister’s Office and the NGO Bureau for imposing severe restrictions on independent human rights organizations under the guise of national security regulations. They argued that these barriers must be dismantled so that rights organizations can operate freely and contribute to accountability efforts.

Given the high number of human

rights violations over the years, participants recognized that ensuring justice will be a time-consuming process. They emphasized the necessity of preserving historical documentation of these incidents through official government directives—whether from the Directorate General of Forces Intelligence (DGFI), RAB, the police, or the Detective Branch (DB)—to ensure that records are not erased.

Some discussants suggested that reports of enforced disappearances and extrajudicial killings published in newspapers should also be preserved and that individuals accused of human rights violations should be banned from leaving the country.

Leveraging International Organizations for Human Rights Protection

Participants highlighted that Bangladesh has deliberately refrained from signing or ratifying several key international human rights covenants. Many argued that there must be a public demand to push the government toward adopting these agreements and ensuring compliance with international human rights norms.

Several participants emphasized the importance of engaging international human rights organizations in monitoring the situation in Bangladesh. They suggested incorporating the UN’s Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights into a national action plan to align Bangladesh with global human rights standards.

Some discussants pointed to Bangladesh’s Transgender Rights Bill (2018) as an example of international influence, noting that it received support and funding from the Asian Development Bank (ADB). However, they criticized the government for failing to implement the bill effectively despite receiving funding. Participants urged the government to prioritize enacting policies that ensure the protection of transgender rights and other vulnerable communities.

The dialogue was moderated by CGS’s Executive Director, Zillur Rahman, and featured several distinguished speakers. The speakers were;

  • Brig. Gen. Dr. M Shakhawat Hossain, Advisor of the Ministry of Shipping, Labor, and Employment
  • Munira Khan, Chair, Centre for Governance Studies (CGS)
  • Pallab Chakma, Executive Director, Kapaeeng Foundation
  • Joya Shikder, Trans Women Activist
  • Shihab Uddin Khan, Barrister-at-Law, Advocate, Supreme Court of Bangladesh
  • Ashraf Kaiser, Political Analyst
  • Bobby Hajjaj, Chairman of the Nationalist Democratic Movement – NDM
  • Ilirara Dewan, Women’s Rights Activist
  • Nur Khan, Director, Ain O Shalish Kendra (ASK)
  • Sanjida Islam, Organizer, Mayer Daak
  • Barrister Asaduzzaman Fuad, Joint Member Secretary, AB Party
  • Dilruba Shormin, Advocate, Supreme Court of Bangladesh
  • Advocate Subrata Chowdhury, Executive President, Gono Forum
  • Saleh Ahmed, Political Observer
  • Rashed Khan, General Secretary, Gonoodhikar Parishad
  • Barrister Ahsan Habib Bhuiyan, Lawyer of the Supreme Court of Bangladesh
  • Dr. Shakhawat Hossain Sayantha, Secretary General, G9
  • Alena Khan, Advocate, Supreme Court of Bangladesh
  • Naima Akter Rita, Student Leader, Jagannath University
  • Tauhid Siam, Student Leader, Jahangirnagar University