Centre for Governance Studies, Dhaka

Appendix A

Selected Tables

AllSizeSectorIf women- owned/managed
SmallMediumManu.ServiceWomenOther
%%%%%%
Registry and permit/ license28.528.229.628.328.828.628.5
Tax office21.622.518.323.020.324.221.0
Local Government/ City corporation/Municipality19.518.523.118.320.820.519.2
Law Enforcement Agencies18.518.219.517.519.524.217.1
Environmental Directorate15.115.513.612.517.818.614.2
Customs Banks and Finances11.6 9.810.5 10.816.0 5.913.5 10.89.8 8.813.0 10.68.9 11.9
Directorate of National Consumer Rights Protection8.57.611.87.89.37.58.1
State Owned Enterprises8.07.88.96.59.55.69.2
Labour ministry5.35.44.75.84.86.25.0
Bonded warehouse2.12.21.81.82.53.11.9
Don’t know/No answer31.633.126.031.531.826.133.0
Base-All respondents800631169400400161639

Table 1: Most Corrupt Departments

Table 1: Reasons of Corruption in the Business Sector of the Country

AllSizeSectorIf women- owned/managed
SmallMediumManu.ServiceWomenOther
%%%%%%
Greed for money/asset35.935.736.733.538.336.635.7
Lack of transparency at high levels of government32.932.833.130.535.334.232.6
Business syndicates25.625.426.629.322.028.025.0
Regulations and Inefficient Control19.817.329.016.822.821.119.4
Merger/(collusion) of business and political interests15.115.214.812.817.518.014.4
Frequent use corrupt practices by the large corporations11.611.711.211.511.811.211.7
Slow Judicial Process and Higher Degree of Morale Hazard6.67.05.34.09.35.66.9
AllSizeSectorIf women- owned/managed
SmallMediumManu.ServiceWomenOther
%%%%%%
Lack of Courage to Denounce Corrupt Behavior6.16.25.94.57.85.66.3
There is a lot of poorly controlled/black money in the economy.6.46.27.16.86.05.06.7
Cultural Environments that Condone Corruption6.46.07.74.38.56.86.3
Refused3.94.41.83.84.03.14.1
Don’t know/No answer13.914.611.215.012.813.014.1
Base-All respondents800631169400400161639

Table 2: Q302. Degree of Corruption Faced at Each Point of Obstacle (Top 10 obstacles)

Degree of corruption faced at the obstacleNo Obstacle at allModerate ObstacleMajor ObstacleDon’t Know/ Not SureBase-Respective Respondents
Starting and Registering a business40.1%37.8%18.0%4.1%800
Obtaining Business Licenses39.8%39.1%18.8%2.4%800
Getting electricity and utili- ties-License and Connection54.8%24.6%15.9%4.8%800
Payment Tax and VAT59.4%27.0%10.3%3.2%715
Tax and VAT-TIN Collec- tion/VAT Registration Certifi- cate/Tax Holiday/Return of Duty57.5%26.8%11.4%4.3%713
Fire License65.4%22.6%9.5%2.5%674
Obtaining Environmental Certificate38.7%33.8%23.9%3.6%631
Getting credit / access to fi- nance41.3%27.5%21.8%9.5%601
Safety and health require- ments77.0%14.1%5.8%3.1%548
Labor market regulations66.9%21.6%8.2%3.4%537

Table 3: Forms of Corruption, SMEs Face or Experience in Doing Business in Bangladesh

AllSizeSectorIf women- owned/managed
SmallMediumManu.ServiceWomenOther
%%%%%%
Bribery77.977.379.974.381.577.078.1
Political Influence60.158.566.355.564.861.559.8
Extortion46.345.648.540.352.348.445.7
Nepotism43.943.146.738.849.049.142.6
Patronage43.141.549.138.547.844.142.9
Lobbying41.840.147.936.846.850.339.6
Fraud37.137.635.532.042.340.436.3
Embezzlement of Funds26.126.026.620.332.026.726.0
AllSizeSectorIf women- owned/managed
SmallMediumManu.ServiceWomenOther
%%%%%%
Don’t know/No answer5.96.05.36.85.04.36.3
Base-All respondents800631169400400161639

Table 4: Incidence of Paying Bribe for Obtaining These Services by the SMEs

AllSizeSectorIf women- owned/managed
SmallMediumManu.ServiceWomenOther
%%%%%%
Business license36.435.240.839.033.836.636.3
For renewal of licenses31.832.030.833.330.337.330.4
Environmental Clearance Certificate21.921.722.522.021.832.319.2
For the use of Utilities (Water, Gas, and Electricity)20.619.724.324.317.021.720.3
TIN and VAT Certificate from National Board of Revenues12.111.614.212.312.013.711.7
Product Quality and Testing Report5.65.46.56.05.36.25.5
For Obtaining Loans from Nationalized Commercial Banks5.15.15.36.34.09.34.1
Activities Relating to Import, Export and Customs5.84.98.98.82.87.55.3
Obtaining Government Tender3.02.25.94.02.02.53.1
Did not have to pay bribe47.448.742.644.050.846.047.7
Refused/No answer9.58.413.610.38.86.810.2
Base-All respondents800631169400400161639

Table 5: Incidence of Paying Bribe During One Year Prior to Covid 19 and Prior to the Survey by the SMEs

AllSizeSectorIf women- owned/managed
SmallMediumManu.ServiceWomenOther
%%%%%%
Within One Year prior to Covid 19 Pandemic:
Paid bribe20.519.524.318.522.525.519.2
Did not pay bribe74.475.968.676.372.570.275.4
Refused/No answer5.14.67.15.35.04.35.3
Within One Year prior to the survey:
Paid bribe21.318.432.022.819.827.319.7
Did not pay bribe72.876.259.870.075.567.174.2
Refused/No answer6.05.48.37.34.85.66.1
Base-All respondents800631169400400161639

Table 6: Purposes of paying bribe in the 12 months prior to the COVID-19

AllSizeSectorIf women- owned/managed
SmallMediumManu.ServiceWomenOther
%%%%%%
License renewal68.967.573.271.666.770.768.3
Obtaining business license29.328.531.728.430.026.830.1
To get utility connection18.920.314.617.620.019.518.7
To pay less amount of tax15.216.312.216.214.417.114.6
To release products from customs13.411.419.517.610.07.315.4
Obtaining government contract5.54.97.38.13.30.07.3
To complete the contract2.41.64.92.72.20.03.3
Others6.78.12.46.86.79.85.7
Base- Those paid bribe16412341749041123
AllSizeSectorIf women- owned/managed
SmallMediumManu.ServiceWomenOther
%%%%%%
Only way to get work done75.971.685.270.382.379.574.6
Would’ve taken significant time18.822.411.125.311.415.919.8
Would’ve taken significant effort3.54.31.93.33.82.34.0
Faulty documentation on my part1.81.71.91.12.52.31.6
Base-Those had to pay bribe in last year (prior to the sur- vey)17011654917944126

Table 7: Reason Behind Paying Bribe

Table 8: Incidence of Paying Bribe for Obtaining These Services by the SMEs

AllSizeSectorIf women- owned/managed
SmallMediumManu.ServiceWomenOther
%%%%%%
Building public awareness54.653.957.451.058.359.053.5
Strong enforcement measures of law and punishment47.548.245.050.045.047.847.4
Transparency in administra- tive decision-making28.128.726.025.830.525.528.8
Close, strict supervisory role by the high officials24.125.020.722.026.317.425.8
Ensuring justice23.624.620.122.025.323.623.6
Good governance23.624.221.324.023.319.924.6
AllSizeSectorIf women- owned/managed
SmallMediumManu.ServiceWomenOther
%%%%%%
Strengthening state control over public administration22.922.823.120.325.527.321.8
Strengthening civil control over public administration11.612.77.711.012.310.611.9
Increasing public employees’ salaries6.36.55.35.57.08.15.8
Base-All respondents800631169400400161639

Table 9: Q516. When a Government Agent Acts Against the Rules, if One Usually go to Another Official or to His Superior and Get the Correct Treatment Without Recourse to Unofficial Payments

AllSizeSectorIf women- owned/managed
SmallMediumManu.ServiceWomenOther
%%%%%%
Never29.630.327.233.326.027.330.2
Seldom37.436.341.436.838.037.337.4
Frequently10.010.58.39.810.311.29.7
Mostly7.87.97.16.09.59.97.2
Always8.98.79.57.310.56.89.4
Not sure6.46.36.57.05.87.56.1
Base-All respondents800631169400400161639

Table 10: Q518. Level of Confidence on Judicial System in Dealing with Corruption and If Judiciary Acts Independ-

AllSizeSectorIf women- owned/managed
SmallMediumManu.ServiceWomenOther
%%%%%%
Level of confidence in dealing with corruption:
Not at all22.522.721.924.021.019.923.2
Little15.014.616.617.312.814.315.2
Moderate45.545.246.744.546.546.045.4
Very High17.017.614.814.319.819.916.3
If judiciary acts independent of the government:
Not at all30.830.730.835.026.526.131.9
Partly36.635.540.831.841.544.734.6
Completely19.019.517.216.521.516.119.7
Not sure6.36.84.17.35.36.26.3
Refused to answer3.12.94.14.02.34.32.8
Don’t know4.34.63.05.53.02.54.7
Base-All respondents800631169400400161639

ent of the Government Table 11: Q521. Level of Satisfaction with the Performance of Chambers of Commerce and Business Associations

AllSizeSectorIf women- owned/managed
SmallMediumManu.ServiceWomenOther
%%%%%%
Very dissatisfied/ Somewhat dissatisfied20.821.916.621.520.027.319.1
Neither satisfied nor dissatisfied11.011.310.111.310.810.611.1
Somewhat satisfied/ Very satisfied55.152.963.356.054.349.156.7
Don’t Know / Not Sure13.113.910.111.315.013.013.1
Base-All respondents800631169400400161639

in Fighting Corruption

Table 12: Q521. A Comparison Between Members of Chambers of Commerce and Business Associations and Non-

AllMember of any associationNon-member
Very dissatisfied/Somewhat dissatisfied20.820.720.8
Neither satisfied nor dissatisfied11.012.410.6
Very satisfied/Somewhat satisfied55.160.953.6
Don’t Know / Not Sure13.15.915.1
Base-All respondents800169631

member

Table 13: Q522. Willingness to Join a Private Sector Coalition

AllSizeSectorIf women- owned/managed
SmallMediumManu.ServiceWomenOther
%%%%%%
No, definitely not join12.812.414.212.812.816.811.7
No, likely not join8.99.47.19.58.34.310.0
Maybe, need to learn more6.56.27.75.87.35.06.9
Yes, probably join12.912.514.214.511.39.313.8
Yes, definitely join55.956.653.354.057.861.554.5
Unsure/ Don’t Know3.13.03.63.52.83.13.1
Base-All respondents800631169400400161639

Table 14: Opinion on Effectiveness of the Six Selected Proposals to Combat Corruption

AllSizeSectorIf women- owned/managed
SmallMediumManu.ServiceWomenOther
%%%%%%
1. Tougher penalties relating to acts of corruption76.578.075.177.478.373.978.2
2. Making all democratic and educational institutions of Government accountable and dedicated to practice governance through admin- istrative and political reform.68.073.171.072.677.376.471.7
3. Improved efficiency of judiciary (prosecutors, judges, police)67.872.366.971.174.570.871.2
4. Implementing codes of conduct and maintaining the standards of integrity70.070.876.372.074.073.371.7
5. The existence of training programs for staff on the integrity of public and private sector65.566.671.067.569.568.367.3
6. Ensuring governance at each office of Government through enforcing monitoring by Ombudsman65.368.664.567.870.365.268.4
Don’t know/No answer5.54.63.04.33.03.14.5
Base-All respondents800631169400400161639
Form of firmAll AverageWomen owned/ managedOther
Sole Proprietorship53.937.957.9
Partnership30.536.029.1
Limited Company15.626.113.0
Base-All respondents800631169
AllSizeSectorIf women- owned/managed
SmallMediumManu.ServiceWomenOther
%%%%%%
Position of the respondent in the establishment
Owner37.943.317.842.833.026.740.7
General Manager/Manager42.337.759.239.844.846.641.2
Managing Director7.56.810.16.38.87.57.5
Director5.16.01.84.06.39.34.1

Table 15: Form of Business

Table 16: Profile of the Surveyed Establishments

AllSizeSectorIf women- owned/managed
SmallMediumManu.ServiceWomenOther
%%%%%%
Years in business
Up to 10 years31.331.530.229.832.828.631.9
11-15 years22.323.019.525.319.327.321.0
16-25 years26.126.624.325.526.824.226.6
More than 25 years20.418.926.019.521.319.920.5
Forms of Firm
Sole Proprietorship53.957.540.261.346.537.957.9
Partnership30.531.128.419.541.536.029.1
Limited Company15.611.431.419.312.026.113.0
Base-All respondents800631169400400161639
Listing status of the Limited Companies
Listed15.215.315.113.018.816.714.5
Non-Listed84.884.784.987.081.383.385.5
Base-All respondents125725377484283
Type of Establishments
Manufacturing Sectors50.047.459.8100.00.037.953.1
Service Sectors50.052.640.20.0100.062.146.9
Location of business by area type
Urban8.99.27.712.35.57.59.2
Rural91.190.892.387.894.592.590.8
Location of business zone type
EPZ/SEZ1.00.81.81.80.30.61.1
Industrial Zone18.015.527.232.04.020.517.4
Outside81.083.771.066.395.878.981.5
If the business is a woman-owned or managed
Woman-owned or managed20.119.323.115.325.0100.00.0
Not owned or managed by woman79.980.776.984.875.00.0100.0
If the business is a member of any business chamber or association
Member of any association21.115.741.432.010.324.220.3
Non-member78.984.358.668.089.875.879.7
Base-All respondents800631169400400161639