Executive Summary
1.1 The Survey
This survey, as a part of a project which seeks to understand the depth of corruption in Bangladesh as experienced by its citizens and Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs), examines the entrepreneurs’ perceptions about the nature, causes and practices of corruption in the SME sector, with a view to developing an action plan involving the SMEs to further inclusive, accountable, and corruption-free system of governance.
The survey was conducted among 800 nationally representative SMEs, including 400 manufacturing and 400 service sector enterprises. Interviews were conducted through Computer Assisted Telephone Interview (CATI) method between mid-October and mid December 2021.
1.2 Summary of salient findings
1.2.1 Corruption perception and causes
Almost nine out of 10 enterprises involved in the SME sector perceive that corruption is widespread in the sector A large majority (62.4%) report that corruption is well-rooted/integrated in the system, and an even larger share (71.3%) of them feel that resorting to corruption can help boost market competitiveness. More than half of the respondents noted feeling that strict government regulations are causing corruption to thrive, and this perception is even more common among smaller enterprises. In part due to these perceptions, a majority (61%) of surveyed SMEs have chosen to bypass regulations and operate informally.
Desire for money or assets as well as the lack of transparency at the higher government level motivates this rampant corruption, according to most of the respondents, but they also identified a host of other contributing factors. Some of the reasons most cited by SMEs included lax enforcement of anti-corruption laws (86.2%) and non-enforcement of laws intended to reduce corruption (79.5%). The absence of professionalism of the public officials (77.4%), and their demands for kickbacks for awarding contracts (73.9%) contribute to issues on the demand side, while businesses seeking advantages by offering bribes or seeking special favors (73.9%) stimulates corruption on the supply side. Inadequate coverage of corruption in the media (72.8%) represents another contributory factor.
1.2.2 Forms and sites of corruption
The two most cited forms of corruption faced by the SMEs are bribery (77.9%) and use of political influence (60.1%). These are followed by extortion (46.3%), nepotism (43.9%), and undue patronage (43.1%). These forms of corruption reflect the overall situation in social and political arena affecting the economic sector in general. SMEs are affected more by corruption in the local government (53.4%) than the national government (27.6%). Bribery, use of connections with influential people (68.4%), and networking with public officials are viewed as the easiest way to get public services (68.4%) and thrive illegally.
1.2.3 Nature and acceptability of Corruption
Despite pervasive corruption and its systemic support, most surveyed SMEs do not support corrupt practices. About 70% of respondents described it as unacceptable, compared to only a quarter that feels that some level of corruption is acceptable. These feelings reflect the everyday experiences of SME entrepreneurs regarding corruption. More than half (52.06%) of the respondents reported that they did have to pay a bribe for obtaining important services such as securing and renewing licenses, use of utilities, obtaining a Tax Identification Number (TIN) and Value Added Tax (VAT) certificate in the year prior to COVID-19, and this overall pattern of corruption has remained the same over the past year.
However, reported incidences of this type of corruption could be low because many SMEs either avoid these types of business services or are not required to use them. Among these services, obtaining and renewing licenses featured particularly high incidences of bribery (36.4% and 31.8%, respectively). Two-thirds of those who paid bribes did so because they felt that they were necessary to receive the services, and the second most common reason was to save time. The most commonly cited recipients of bribes included the license and registration authority (28.8%), the tax office (21.6%), the local government/City corporation/municipality (19.5%), the property registration office (13.5%), the Environmental Directorate (12.9%), and law enforcement agencies (10.6%). As such, it is evident that the offices that businesses have to contact for basic operations and services operate as the primary sites of corruption.
Despite the prevalence of corruption, enthusiasm for submitting complaints to authorities remains low. Only 2.3% of the respondents have ever reported a complaint, yet more than 70% of those respondents reported a negative outcome to the complaint process.
1.2.4 Anticorruption steps and suggestions
Despite the government’s repeated assertion that it has adopted a “zero-tolerance” policy, less than half of the respondents (46%) said that local and national government have taken some steps to reduce corruption. However, a majority of this group did not feel that these steps have produced positive impacts. One of the key issues explored regarding the anti-corruption process of the government was the corruption reporting process. Two aspects were probed: effectiveness and ease. Both have produced divided responses in almost equal measure. That means that the processes have not been attractive to the SMEs. One key area where overwhelming majority of respondents (72.8%) expressed dissatisfaction is degrading protection of whistle-blowers, as most SMEs felt that they are poorly protected.
Considering the ubiquitous corruption in society and the SME sector, the survey respondents made a wide array of suggestions on how to prevent corruption. While building public awareness (54.6%) received the largest support, almost half of the respondents underscored the necessity of implementing strong enforcement measures of law and punishment (47.5%). The third most frequently suggested measure was maintaining transparency in administrative decision making (28.1%). “Strict supervision of high officials” also received a strong response from survey participants (24.1%). Respondents generally expressed confidence in the judiciary’s ability as an institution to combat corruption, but a large number of respondents (67.8%) still suggested that the efficiency of the judiciary warrants improvement.
The respondents also suggested steps that the SME sector itself can take to effectively combat corruption. They underscored the necessity of enhancing integrity in the private sector. More than two-thirds favored tougher penalties for those involved in acts of corruption, and seventy percent supported implementing codes of conduct.
The way forward
While most of the SMEs (55.1%) were satisfied with the performance of chambers of commerce and business associations in fighting corruption in the public sector, more than 78% of the enterprises were open to joining a private sector coalition for collective action to promote business integrity and lead an anti-corruption effort. Only a smaller segment (21.7%) of the respondents were not interested.
1.3 Concluding observations
The presence of corruption in society and in the SME sector is widely acknowledged along with the understanding of the principal means of such corrupt acts, the immediate and underlying factors, and the institutional culture contributing to it. As such, prevention of corruption, however difficult, is not an insurmountable task. However, weak institutional processes, the absence of accountability mechanisms, and a lack of positive results of prior initiatives discourage SMEs from reporting corruption to the authorities.
The judicial system and business chambers and associations can become agents of change in preventing and reducing corruption in the country, if utilized effectively. In addition, there is enthusiasm among SME entrepreneurs for developing an internal mechanism and a coalition within the sector to combat corruption.
1.4 Recommendations
These recommendations are based on the findings of the survey
| To the Government | ||
|---|---|---|
| | Simplify the process for obtaining and renewing licenses and certificates through reduction of | ||
| points of contact and increasing the use of information technology for approval processes and | ||
| documentation. | ||
| | Reduce regulatory requirements, especially for small firms, and incentivize SMEs to avoid | ||
| bypassing regulations. | ||
| | Create an environment facilitating SMEs reporting incidents of corruption and protect them under | ||
| the Public‐interest Information Disclosure Act (Provide Protection), 2011 (popularly referred as the | ||
| Whistle-blower Protection Act). | ||
| | Build public awareness through mass media and other formal and informal channels against all | ||
| types of corruption, including bribery, political influence, extortion, nepotism, undue patronage, | ||
| fraud, and embezzlement of money and property. | ||
| | Demonstrate unequivocal political commitment to combating corruption by enhancing the | ||
| accountability mechanism in the public sector. | ||
| | Ensure strong enforcement of law and punitive measures. | ||
| | Appoint an independent Ombudsman at each office of the government with the power of | ||
| monitoring and enforcement of laws. | ||
| | Improve the efficiency of judiciary, including prosecutors and judges, to combat corruption in | ||
| public and private sectors. | ||
| To the SME Sector | ||
| | Make chambers and associations express an unequivocal commitment to combating corruption, | ||
| play a greater role in ensuring the accountability of the government, and take specific measures | ||
| to combat corruption. | ||
| | Adopt an internal code of conduct and code of ethics and create a mechanism to monitor these | ||
| codes | ||
| | Create an effective private-sector coalition for collective action to promote business integrity and | ||
| work on anti-corruption measures. |
